A punch in the face of the PIE Act


A punch in the face of the PIE Act
Source: BusinessTech - 8 May 2026

The Department of Human Settlements has officially gazetted the PIE Amendment Bill of 2026, a Bill that legal experts say is a big win for property rights in South Africa.

The proposed legislation represents a major shift for property owners, municipalities, and the courts, which have spent years grappling with lengthy and costly eviction disputes.

Ann-Suhet Marx, Director and Head of Litigation at VDM Incorporated, said the Bill seeks to amend the Prevention of Illegal Eviction from and Unlawful Occupation of Land Act of 1998, commonly known as the PIE Act.

Marx said the reforms are specifically designed to close loopholes that have allowed bad-faith occupiers and organised syndicates to exploit the legal system.

“For the first time, the law is specifically targeting the syndicates behind these invasions, rather than just the desperate families caught in the middle,” she said.

The proposed amendments include tougher penalties for anyone involved in organised land invasions in South Africa.

These include fines of up to R2 million and possible asset forfeiture for individuals who illegally “sell” plots of land they do not own.

Marx said these measures are aimed at dismantling the financial incentives behind large-scale invasions that have increasingly burdened municipalities and private property owners.

“Our courts have been a frontline for a constitutional tug-of-war for years. The 2026 Bill is a direct response to years of judicial ‘gridlock’ where landowners and municipalities were left with orders they simply couldn’t enforce,” she said.

While high-profile land invasions often dominate public attention, Marx said the bill could also provide relief for ordinary South Africans who own small rental properties.

“For a pensioner who relies on a garden cottage for income, or a family that has saved for years for a single rental unit, the current legal system is often a death sentence,” she said.

“They simply can’t afford a R150,000 legal bill and an 18-month wait to reclaim their own property.” To address this, the bill introduces several new mechanisms intended to speed up disputes and lower legal costs.
One of the key proposals is the introduction of low-cost mediation processes that would allow smaller landlords and tenants to settle disputes without immediately resorting to expensive High Court litigation.

The amendments would also give courts clearer powers to distinguish between families facing genuine hardship and so-called “professional” non-paying tenants who intentionally abuse the legal system to delay evictions.

Additionally, landlords who can prove they are suffering undue financial hardship may be able to access a fast-tracked eviction process.

Marx said this is intended to prevent situations where owners fall into foreclosure while waiting months, or even years, for an eviction order to be enforced.

The proposed changes are also heavily influenced by several landmark court rulings that exposed weaknesses in the current PIE Act framework.

Marx cited a recent Constitutional Court ruling, which highlighted the difficulties of evicting vulnerable occupiers, even when alternative accommodation was available.

She also referenced a court ruling involving the City of Johannesburg, where the municipality was required to provide alternative accommodation before evictions could proceed, creating years of legal stalemates.

Under the new bill, courts would be able to impose fixed expiry dates on temporary accommodation arrangements to avoid endless delays.

Marx said the legislation’s provisions for mandatory mediation and automatic joinder of municipalities in eviction matters could significantly reduce litigation timelines.

“We’re moving from a system of ‘eviction at all costs’ to one of ‘regulated resolution’. By closing the loopholes that allowed bad-faith actors to exploit the Grootboom legacy of housing rights, we are restoring the balance that the Constitution originally intended,” she said.

The public has until mid-June 2026 to submit comments on the Bill before it proceeds to the next stage of the legislative process.


pie actillegal occupationsquatterslandlordstenantsplakkerseviction
• S H A R E •